Monday, April 14, 2014

TODAY APRIL 14: SOLEMN IN 2014; GRIM ANNIVERSARY FROM 1972


NYPD BURIES OFFICER GUERRA WITH HONOR
P.O. CARDILLO’S FAMILY STILL WAITS FOR HONOR
TWO TRAGIC DEATHS
THAT ALTERED NYPD POLICY


TAGS: NYPD OFFICER GUERRA FUNERAL, NYPD FIRE RESPONSE POLICY,

NYPD OFFICER PHILLIP CARDILLO, MOSQUE #7,

NYPD HISTORY, NYPD TRADITION,

SERVICE, SACRIFICE, HONOR, DUTY, NYC

(Updated)

(Monday April 14, 2014 Rockaway Beach, Queens, NYC)  Two men separated by a generation, one honored and laid to eternal rest today, the other a man whose effort to honor is itself a source of contention. For some this inconsistency reflects the reality that New York is a tale of two cities but, it really isn’t.  It is more a single city of a million tales, of thousands of stories and neighborhoods, characters famed, infamous, known and anonymous.  This City has a storied history and every day new pages are written into that dense tome.  We have known great triumphs in our past and have suffered through dark days.  There is an almost homeostatic quality to this living, breathing beast of 10 million individuals, opposing forces and influences reflected in our governance and tolerance, in what we think we share and that which  we all will never have in common beyond the fact we can all identify as New Yorkers.  The unique dynamics that function like atomic particles and hold this City together as an entity somehow make it all work.  For the most part despite the ups and downs, it remains, we remain.  And there are so many stories.  This is a story of a date that will live in NYPD both as a day of infamy and a day of sacrifice; April 14th.

The briny scent wafting over the gathered mass of dress blue uniforms along the streets in Far Rockaway is a world apart from the urban scents of auto and bus emissions and ethnic foods on 116th Street in Harlem that seem to defy the fact that the Atlantic Ocean is just a few miles way. Two different worlds in one City:  the largest and most complex and diverse in America.

Here in the part of South Queens that many New Yorkers never venture out to, the strips of beachfront where Hurricane Sandy’s roiling tides and winds delivered so much deadly destruction not too long ago, a 38 year old man; a son, husband father and Cop, was laid to rest amid thousands of his fellow Officers looking like a human ocean of blue extending to the shoreline horizon.  NYPD Officer Dennis Guerra was buried after succumbing to injuries sustained when he and his partner responded to reports of a fire in a housing project building in Brooklyn.  As is customary for all line of duty deaths he was given the righteous, respectful send off by the NYPD he had served so well.

If a crow were to take flight on an ocean breeze current from here and land a few short miles to the northwest, it might alight atop a squat, stolid building with a plain concrete façade, the longtime home of NYPD’s 28th Precinct.  Exactly 42 years ago today another NYPD Officer, Phillip Cardillo was shot and lost his life in a line of duty death six days later.  He too was a son, father, and husband and a Cop but his funeral was not attended by the Mayor or Police Commissioner, no luminaries or politicians saw fit to pay their respects.  To this day an effort to honor Officer Cardillo with a mural to be painted on the side of the Precinct House parking lot wall and by renaming the segment of the block the 28th Precinct sits on after Officer Cardillo remains a “controversial” issue that sadly and obviously the new NYPD Commissioner wants to avoid. 

April 14, 1972

One has to travel back in time to the City as it was on April 14, 1972.  Racial unrest had spread from the Deep South and was now being waged in cities across the northeast out to the west coast.  The peaceful “passive resistance” strategy championed by the Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King was not bringing enough changes in society for the younger generation of “civil rights activists”.  These younger leaders were far more militant, strident and aggressive than anything Dr. King could have imagined or condoned.  But, the Black Panthers and the Nation of Islam were taking up arms against law enforcement officer all over the country and, by Spring in 1972 the NYPD was in a low level hot guerilla war with these angry armed factions.

After a fake 911 call reporting Officer’s in need of assistance was placed from Mosque #7 on 116th Street, a Mosque lead by a firebrand Black separatist, Louis Farrakhan, where Malcolm X had prayed before the militants in his own movement assassinated him.  When two Police Officers arrived at the Mosque they entered only to be surrounded by a group of 12 to 15 men who beat and kicked them savagely and locked the doors so no one else could enter.  In the course of this melee one of the assailants grabbed Officer Cardillo’s weapon and fired at point blank range into the man’s chest.  Eventually other Cops gained access to the Mosque.  By that time all involved had taken refuge in the basement of the building.  While officers on the scene frantically tried to transport their wounded brothers to urgent medical care other Officers were making arrests in the basement.  On the street outside a large crowd had gathered quickly and before long a riotous atmosphere cast a dark pall over the block as one Police car burned and rocks and other items were being rained down on the Police from the surrounding rooftops. 

Before long Louis Farrakhan appeared in the basement with Congressmen Charlie Rangel, yes THAT Charlie Rangel and, in no uncertain terms informed the Police Officers making the arrests that if they did not release the suspects immediately, the situation outside would intensify.  Essentially, these two characters dissuaded one of the top ranking NYPD members on the scene Ben Ward, yes THAT Ben Ward, to allow the suspects to remain in the Mosque while the NYPD was ordered to retreat.  This episode was not only a damaging milestone for our City, it remains one of the most raw, painful, insulting and contentious in the history of the NYPD.

Even now, more than four decades after Officer Cardillo was buried without the honor and respect that was due him for the sordid, dishonorable reasons of political expediency and to pacify the Black community.  To this very day all efforts to pay respect for his service and sacrifice by either renaming a segment of the street in front of the 28th Precinct or painting a memorial mural on the Precinct’s parking lot wall, continue to be rebuffed by the local Community Board on behalf of the small cadre of self-proclaimed, self-styled Black activists, African-American blowhards and a peanut choir of similar cooks and cranks who are adamantly anti-NYPD.  One of the Community Board members said that if Officer Cardillo’s death was going to be recognized in that neighborhood, on that block, that it would, “Open old wounds”.  Well, the members of NYPD past and present have been living with that same wound still open and bleeding.  Once again the cowardice of an Administration and an NYPD Commissioner is obviously a powerfully restraining force that has laid bare the distinct lack of integrity and propriety of Mayor Bill de Blasio and, even more sickening, Commissioner Bill Bratton.

Books have been written about the “incident” at Mosque #7 and, as a result of that event NYPD policy for responding to calls to any religious building or site was rewritten.  Now Officers on patrol cannot enter a religious building be it a Catholic Church, Synagogue, Mosque or other house of worship or temple, until there is at least a ranking superior on site.

APRIL 14, 2014

Officer Guerra who was laid to rest today was not alive when Officer Cardillo lost his life.  Although 42 years separate their deaths, they are both members of a continuous, steady, storied lineage of an organization that honors its history and traditions as much as it does each man and woman who has ever served. 

Officer Guerra died as a result of injuries sustained that are not common for Police Officers line of duty death.  But, that is irrelevant on this day.  He and his still hospitalized partner responded to a fire and it was the toxic smoke from that fire that felled them as quickly and effectively as shotgun toting thugs.  Since that fire the NYPD has already announced new protocols for Officers as “first responders” to a fire scene.  This is a case of fixing the fence after the herd has escaped but, it might save a future life.  It is difficult to say.

Policy and protocol do not trump courage, dedication and sacrifice.  What the members of NYPD respond to day in day out, 24/7, 365 days a year are as many and varied an array of scenarios as Officers in any other jurisdiction will ever see throughout their career.  That is not an insult to other Police Departments or Law Enforcement Agencies; it is the simple reality of policing in New York City.



Hopefully no one will read this as a comparison between the two Officers.  It is not; it is a statement on how even though the state of affairs in our City may vary from time to time, through good times and bad, one consistent, solid chain that keeps it all together is the continuum of the NYPD and its traditions and, despite the inherent danger the Job entails, there will always be men and women of good decent desire to serve.
 








Copyright The Brooding Cynyx 2014 © All Rights Reserved



Thursday, April 10, 2014

KNIFE CONTROL: WE NEED IT NOW




MASS SLASHING SPREE AT

SUBURBAN PITTSBURGH HIGH SCHOOL
Alex Hribal, the suspect in the stabbings at the Franklin Regional High School
 is taken from a district magistrate after he was arraigned on charges in the attack
 on Wednesday, April 9, 2014 in Export, Pa. (Keith Srakocic /AP)


TAGS: PITTSBURGH AREA HIGH SCHOOL STABBING, 21 HS STUDENTS
INJURED, MASS CAUSALTY EVENTS, KNIFE CONTROL,
CYNICAL SATORICAL OBSERVATIONS,
PUBLIC EDUCATION, EDUCATION INEQUALITIES,
JAILS, PRISONS, PENITENTERIES AS MENTAL HEALTH FACILITIES
(PLEASE READ ALL THE WAY THRU TO THE END)


(Thursday April 10, 2014, Pittsburgh, PA)  In the wake of a slashing spree yesterday at the High School in Murrysville
that left 21 students and a security guard with varying degrees of slash and stab wounds local, state and federal leaders are calling for more “knife control” legislation.  As the small town of Murrysville just north of Pittsburgh was coming to terms with the shocking events of yesterday some parents and officials were demanding that the issue of knife control to be addressed as a serious threat.  “There are far too many knives in our society.  People are very careless with their knives.  Some knives like penknives, Boy Scout knives or pocket knives are not as dangerous as kitchen knives, hunting knives, survival knives, carving knives, boning knives, sabers, daggers, swords, machetes, and some of the larger bladed implements that are out there”, said a man who would only identify himself as Stanley for fear that he might become a target for a stabbing or slashing if his identity was revealed.  Others in the community and here in Pittsburg as well echoed Stanley’s opinion.

In Washington, DC the Democratic Senator and Majority Leader hapless Harry Reid went to the Senate floor late yesterday afternoon and made an impassioned plea that “We all wake up to the fact of knife violence.  We should not need to be reminded about this country’s knife problem whenever a mass attack such as we witnessed today in a suburban Pittsburgh High School occurs.  We should be dealing with making this less of a knife culture all the time”.  Democrats have long been advocating for increasingly stricter knife control laws.  The Republicans, on the other side of the political divide, are very knife friendly and received staunch support and financial donations from the National Knife Association (NKA).

NKA Chairman Dwayne La Sagna made a statement at a hastily called press conference at the NKA headquarters in Washington, DC.  La Sagna commented that “We all recognize that what happened today in that Pennsylvania high school was tragic.  However, if we continue to just look at knives as the issue we will never reduce knife violence and knife deaths.  Over 99.9% of Americans own and use knives for the same purposes they have and their families have for generations.  The knife is no more a danger to our society in itself than is the crossbow.  We have ample knife control laws on the books and really need to look at the causative factors with knife violence such as the mental health of young offenders. Knife control is not the answer.  I own many knives and use them safely and responsibly for many purposes.  Maybe parents should be teaching their children more about knives and knife safety”.

Dr. Arlen D. Stutter, a clinical psychiatrist at the Western Pennsylvania Home for Lunatics, is a recognized authority on knife violence particularly among young offenders.  Dr. Stutter noted, “We live in a generally violent society.  As a people we tend to be more aggressive in manner and actions, more impulsive and have plenty of ways for us to safely, productively even, to express our aggressive urges and violent tendencies.  But the young people who commit these mass casualty slashing and stabbing crimes tend to be shy, introverted and, as is usually found in most of them, suffering from a more significant mental health issue ranging from simple idiopathic neurosis to schizophrenia and severe psychopathy.  These troubled youths need early intervention and most should be taking copious amounts of anti-psychotic drugs”. 

If the previous four paragraphs seem a bit ludicrous it is because they are.  They are meant to be.  If you were to go back and reread them and replace the word “gun” every time you saw the word “knife”, you would see just how ludicrous those assertions and statements are.  Make no mistake about it; yesterday’s events are horrifying to imagine.  That they transpired in a school, a place historically of safety, security and refuge makes them even more concerning. One might argue that had that 16 year old student with the knives been armed instead with guns we would be counted dead bodies rather than stab wounds and they are correct.  To a point.  Accessibility to and choice of weapon notwithstanding, a person bent on or driven to commit mass violence will achieve that goal one way or another. The point here is that the topic of "gun control" is asinine. The issue, if it were to be addressed, is "illegal" firearms out on the streets being peddled as easily as a rock of crack or a bag of weed.  Those are the guns that need control not the overwhelming majority of firearms owned and used by responsible people.

As Americans we have to accept certain aspects of our culture and society today that may be a little unsettling at first glance, need to be carefully considered when we debate matters of crime, criminality, mental health, gun ownership, gun control and our cultural obsession with violence.  We are a violent people; we always have been.  Our Country itself was born out of violence, practiced wholesale genocide on the Native American population, fought a brutal Civil War and has never known the true sacrifices that come with military conflict on our shores since the early years of the 1800’s.  The two “World Wars” were fought overseas as were all the other military conflicts in which we became engaged. Having not experienced war in our homeland, in our own cities, towns and communities we have become vicariously violent as spectators of violent sports, video games and more than jaded by the daily news. 

Some will argue that we do not have to “accept” these truths about our society, that we have the power to change it.  After all, we are not some banana republic or “third world nation”: we are American’s dam it, and we can change whatever needs changing.  Alas, if this were so.  We are who we are; we do what we can do.  We might dance around the fringes of an issue such as why many of our young children develop into stalkers, bullies, murderers, arsonists, drug abusers, antisocial personalities and exhibit all the various disorders defined in the textbook of mental disorders.  But, for all the fancy footwork and dancing, for all the studies, panels, experts, blue-ribbon commissions, peer reviewed papers and all the rest, we seem to wind up at the exact same point from which we began. 

For a country as big, diverse and disparate as ours with a multicultural, multiethnic composition, free markets, freedom of speech, religion and all the other traits that make our country what it is, it is a little surprising why we do not have more crime, why we don’t have more frequent mass casualty crimes committed.  We number over 400 million in population and are scattered over this part of the North American continent in big urban centers surrounded by rings suburban and exurban living.  We have smaller cities interspersed throughout rural sections in the continental 48 States and our Constitution, while a little strained and twisted, has served us well.  Our public education system and criminal justice system are profoundly dysfunctional and, if one were to believe that those two entities are not intimately related, they would be very much mistaken.  If as a society we cannot provide an equal education for all of our children regardless of any external factors then we are failing as a society.  When our jails, prisons and penitentiaries become the go-to warehousing place for the mentally ill among us we are falling short.

Our broad systemic failures in public education also pose a serious national security threat.  In a paper sponsored by the Council on Foreign Relations and co-authored by two former Secretaries of State, Henry Kissinger and Condoleezza Rice reported that an alarming number of applicants to enlist in the Armed Forces cannot even pass the basic competency tests for admission to the military.  In a similar study conducted by the RAND Corporation over 25% of potential enlistees were disqualified because they could not achieve a passing grade on that same basic skills test that Drs. Kissinger and Rice evaluated in their work.

Providing a basic education for every child in the country should be among the very top priorities of the federal government.  State and local politics, regional tendencies and any number of extraneous variables should not be impediments to attaining that goal.  Our educators interactions with our children may be the only positive interactions they have with an adult.  This is not about need or merit, nor is it about any of the other red herrings that politicians like to throw out into this debate.  This is a nation-wide problem and it needs to be addressed in a serious manner.

We do not intend to say or even remotely imply that lack of education, poverty, bad neighborhoods or whatever else can be tossed into the excuse pot are “valid” reasons for, or “causes” of violence in our society especially among our youth.  That is simply not the case.  Millions of Americans over generations and hundreds of years have lived in less than ideal circumstances and have gone on to be productive law abiding members of society.  We cannot perform some type of “Mass mental health evaluation” for every child or teenager in the country but, the more of them we can teach – actually get into a classroom and keep them there - the better off we will all be.  Having our youth as “students” allows for them to be casually observed and unofficially evaluated by their educators on a daily basis and it is that level of scrutiny, that noninvasive or confrontational observance that might help a teacher identifies a legitimately “troubled” student before they drop out and pick up a knife…or a gun.  Our public schools lose hundreds of students a month to the streets or town squares.  In some of our largest cities, the biggest urban school districts, the dropout rates are almost at 50%.  That should be unacceptable to every person in the country, to every voter, to every elected official be they members of a local school board or the President of the United States.

Until we assume the responsibility as a people to provide an equal education for every child we will continue our slow but sure backsliding and it will continue to get worse.










Copyright The Brooding Cynyx 2014 © All Rights Reserved

Wednesday, April 9, 2014

THE FACE OF SACRIFICE - NYPD MOURNS LOSS

OFFICER DENNIS GUERRA:

AN EXAMPLE OF VALOR
FLAGS TO FLY AT HALF MAST CITYWIDE
NYPD OFFICER DENNIS GUERRA
LEAVES BEHIND A WIFE AND FOUR CHILDREN

TAGS: R.I.P. OFFICER GUERRA, LINE OF DUTY DEATH,

NYPD MOURNS TRAGIC LOSS, MAYOR DE BLASIO QUOTE COMMENT,

THIN BLUE LINE ONE FIBER THINNER,

NYC, NYPD



(Wednesday April 9, 2014, The Bronx, NYC)  The inadequacy of words is most acutely evident at a time such as this. While a vocabulary exists to express the emotions and feelings in the face of such a tragedy, they all fall short.  They are, after all, just words.  When a man’s actions are such that we are awed by them our vocabulary no matter how expansive and detailed it is it will  not be capable of providing a way to express that which is in our hearts and minds without them sounding tired and worn.  Some of this is because we have over used some words and undervalued some actions.  When the true mettle of a man is exposed for the world to see it is a challenge to give it voice.  That which is so crystal clear in our minds rings hollow and flimsy no matter the words used.

Earlier this morning a New York City Police Officer, 38 year old Dennis Guerra, passed from this earthly realm after succumbing to injuries sustained last Sunday when he and his still hospitalized partner waded into a thick blanket of toxic smoke and carbon monoxide responding to calls about that fire raging on the 13th floor of a New York City Public Housing building on Surf Avenue out in Coney Island.  The fire was intentionally started by a 16 year old resident of that building who set a mattress on fire because he “was bored”.  The ironies are stunning between these two people.  A Cop without a second thought rides the elevator up to the floor where the fire was most intense and is knocked unconscious by the super-heated noxious billows of smoke condensed in the narrow corridors of that building.

But the ironies are not what we dwell on today nor is it the time to allow our anger and rage to distract us from honoring the son, the man, husband, father of four, and eight year NYPD Veteran Officer.   Dennis Guerra epitomizes the term “Public Servant”.  As part of his sworn duty to provide safety and security for our City and our 9 million residents he reacted to aid and assist those residents at the point where the blaze was most threatening. Neither he nor his 36 year old partner and mother of four, Rosa Rodriguez, had any idea what awaited them as soon as that elevator’s doors slid open but that fact did not dissuade them or hamper their response.

Today when Mayor Bill de Blasio said, "On behalf of all 8.4 million New Yorkers, our hearts go out” to the Guerra family he was likely expressing his own feelings because it would be a false claim to say that this NYPD Officer’s death is a “shared loss”, “a shared tragedy”, because it simply isn’t so.  It is however a very real shared loss experienced by the entire NYPD, past and present members alike, and the families of active duty  Police Officers who often must deal with sacrifices from the most minor disruption of family plans to a major life altering catastrophe such as the Guerra’s face from this day forward.

With the public and media typically so intent to tarnish the NYPD and any of its Members over any infraction real, rumored or false, the unseen thousands of acts of humanity, of quiet kindness and humility, of decency and courage are lost; buried beneath the average New Yorker’s consciousness when they think of the men and women serving in NYPD.  Perhaps that is natural and not an exception to a norm that applies in other parts of the country.  Police Officers are Law Enforcers and, as such, they perform all the down and dirty work that must be handled every day and every night to keep the multitude protected from the criminal minority. But often, they are called upon to act in ways far afield from enforcing the law.  That was the scenario last Sunday.

That Officers Guerra and Rodriquez raced to face down a danger not in the form of a man with a gun or a violent drama being played out is also part of what Police Officers do.  They faced a menace in the form of a corridor from hell engulfed in flames with smoke depriving the Officers that essential element for life – oxygen.  As the fire feasted on the available oxygen the clock ticking off the remaining minutes of the life span for both Officers had already begun.  But, a brain deprived of oxygen dies within minutes and it was in that smoke chocked corridor where life departed from Officer Guerra’s body.  Having never awakened from his coma, with no detectable neural activity, in the small early hours of this morning, the Guerra family decided that any life so dependent on the medical technology that can keep a heart beating as long as electricity is available, would be no life at all.  They understood the cruel fact of “brain dead”.

Our City lost one of our good guys today who also happened to earn his living as a Police Officer. But, ask any Police Officer about the thought of losing their life on the Job and to a man or woman you will always get the same reply; it would be a noble way to go especially if my actions saved the life or lives of another.  If Officer Guerra had been asked that question last Saturday night that is almost certainly the answer he would have provided.

Rest in Eternal Peace Officer, your Job here is complete.  EOW.  Amen.









Copyright The Brooding Cynyx 2014 © All Rights Reserved